A Comparative Diagnosis of Utah’s Economic Resilience and Fiscal Sustainability
Utah stands out as a leading state in terms of economic improvement and fiscal stability, earning the top spot in the U.S. News s’ best state rankings. Both the economy and fiscal stability sub-categories are ranked 1st, highlighting the state's strong prospects. The Beehive State is also ranked 1st for its economic outlook by Rich States Poor States. Moreover, the Economic Report to the Governor, produced by the Utah Economic Council in collaboration with the David Eccles School of Business, supports this positive outlook.
To ensure Utah's economic engine continues to operate smoothly, it's crucial to identify areas for improvement. This brief conducts an initial comparative diagnosis of Utah's economic resilience and fiscal sustainability. Economic resilience refers to the state's capacity to anticipate, withstand, and recover from various shocks and disruptions, while fiscal sustainability involves maintaining public finances in a credible and manageable condition over the long term. This analysis places Utah within the context of the 50 states during two distinct periods: 2010-2019 and 2020-2023, examining its performance following the Global Financial Crisis (2007-2009) and in the wake of the Covid-19 Pandemic.
The Performance Scorecard in Table 1 provides an overview of Utah's economic resilience and fiscal sustainability. Key points of these two issues are as follows.
Firstly, the economic shocks experienced by Utah have presented opportunities for accelerated economic growth, yet the state's development level remains relatively modest. The state government has actively promoted economic expansion through significant developmental expenditures and collaboration with stakeholders to enhance the overall business environment. Consequently, key economic indicators such as personal income per capita, population, GDP, employment, and economic establishments demonstrate impressive growth. The overall economic size and developmental progress have improved notably.
However, despite achieving the highest growth rate and advancing 17 levels since 2010, the latest personal income per capita—critical for measuring development—still ranks 31st among states. This suggests that while progress has been substantial, there is room for further improvement to elevate Utah's development status relative to other more advanced states.
Secondly, Utah's fiscal position is considered sustainable, yet several areas for improvement exist, notably the tax burden on households and the substantial size of the public sector measured by the personnel. Specific issues can be assessed through four interconnected dimensions.
Solvency. Utah has been able to generate high revenues and receive substantial federal funding to meet financial obligations.
Growth. The state government's innovative fiscal policies have supported economic growth effectively.
Stability. The growth rates of revenue and expenditure significantly surpass those of GDP and personal income, raising concerns about the government's capacity to meet future obligations with existing burdens.
Fairness. Tax burdens appear equitable for the current generation, and the low public debt suggests that burdens are unlikely to be passed to future generations.
To ensure continued high economic growth and advance Utah's economy among the 50 states, the following issues should be considered:
1. Conduct a comprehensive analysis of Utah's economic resilience and fiscal sustainability with focuses on its competitiveness and burdens to identify optimization opportunities.
2. Elevate the priority on economic growth to sustain high growth rates and elevate Utah's economy to an advanced level. Collaboration with stakeholders is crucial to address economic resilience and fiscal sustainability strategically and proactively.
3. Balance expenditures by prioritizing efficiency, economic growth, and equity. Invest in initiatives that foster economic growth, create a favorable business environment, and enhance livability.
4. Implement solutions to alleviate rising burdens on individuals and the economy. It is important to continue the Governor’s initiative to mitigate the tax burden.
In conclusion, by maintaining a favorable business environment and livability, Utah can sustain its path of high economic growth and foster fairness, attracting more residents to the Beehive State.
Read More